Do your groups offer secular selections or things that aren't "too Christmas-y"?

Do they ever! Our groups pioneered the mix of sacred, secular, and winter-themed songs (including songs like Joni Mitchell's "River," Bob Dylan's "Girl of the North Country," and more) that's becoming more and more popular among holiday vocal groups in NYC. Because we were the first to branch out like that, our groups -- especially the Choristers with their massive repertoire -- can easily prepare a set excluding overtly religious or "Christmas" music. Or, featuring it.